
After Microsoft went down on Thursday, leaving schools, businesses, governments, and individuals in as many as 70 countries unable to access their e-mail and other Microsoft services, the company quickly said, “This was not a hack.”
When the Federal Aviation Administration implemented a Ground Stop on Friday afternoon, preventing airplanes from taking off for more than four hours because of issues with radar and communications, the first thing Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin said was, “This was not a nefarious attack.”
These denials make me (and many other reasonable people) ask: are we under attack? Because when the government or a huge company denies something, my first instinct is to assume that denial is hiding the truth. I know that sounds wrong, but it’s learned behavior. When faced with bad news that might harm their reputation, too many large organizations deny, spin, deny, obfuscate, and deny again. I don’t think they can help it. I recognize that, so I assume the worst.
Also, the symptoms of the air traffic control problems seemed to be the type that could be caused by AI or a computerized attack, not by software that failed to update. Of course, we may never be told the truth. Or by the time we find out when someone writes a tell-all book in three or four years, no one will care.
If so, by Whom?
Let’s assume we are under attack. The question then becomes, by whom? My guess is the Iranians, possibly helped by the Chinese. And let me be clear: that is a wild-ass guess. I have no way to know, just as I don’t know that these actions were attacks and not just coincidences. It is an assumption I am making because I tend to think of the worst-case scenario, not because I have some secret source of inside information. Also, in the end, it doesn’t matter who caused the issue, only that there was an issue.
If we (the government) identify the enemy, what do we do? Do we respond? Do we respond with a cyberattack of our own or militarily? Or do we ignore it, pretend that we don’t know who attacked us, and seek some subtle form of revenge down the road? After all, between Israel and the U.S., we have secretly attacked Iran multiple times, from stealing their nuclear secrets to blowing up Hezbollah pagers. Maybe this is just how the game is played.
It Could Have Been Worse
I see some good news in these episodes: They could have been worse.
During a week in which people worried that the entire Internet could go down, or the electrical grid could be attacked and disabled across the country, a single cloud/computer company was attacked, and it is not even the largest provider of email.
A truly nefarious attack on our air traffic control system could have seen planes slamming into the ground. (Anyone remember Die Hard 2?) In this case, no one was harmed, although at least a million people were inconvenienced. That sucks, but it isn’t much worse than the disruption caused by a bad snowstorm across the Midwest.
If they were indeed attacks, they will soon be forgotten, and life will return to normal. In the meantime, we have important things to worry about, like whether football team X gets to city Y in time to play their game. (A distraction, if there ever was one, but a distraction that made the nightly news.)
I was unaffected by these events because Microsoft is not my primary email provider, and I don’t fly. Had the banking system gone down, the power grid failed, or the cellular network been attacked, it would have been worse. We just have to wonder: did our attackers do their worst? Is that it, or was this just a warm-up?
For me, it’s just another reason to stay on our mountain, protected by distance, isolation, and a lack of reliance on utilities.



